Can I open a demat account if I already have a trading or commodity account?
Last updated: Sep 20262 min readArticle 3 of 7 in Resident Individual
Yes. Having an existing trading or commodity trading account does not prevent you from opening a demat account, whether with Chola Securities or another broker. These are three distinct account types that serve different functions, so having one does not prevent you from opening another.
Why this comes up
This question typically comes from two different situations. The first is someone who opened a trading account without realising a demat account is also required to actually hold securities, they can place an order through the trading account, but the shares need somewhere to settle into once the trade completes. The second is someone who already trades commodities on MCX and now wants to start investing in equities, bonds, or mutual funds, which requires a demat account that a commodity account alone doesn't provide.
How the three accounts relate to each other
A trading account is used to place buy and sell orders on the stock exchange. A demat account is where the securities you buy, shares, bonds, ETFs, and mutual fund units, are held in electronic form once a trade settles. A commodity account works similarly to a trading account, but for commodities like gold, silver, or agricultural products traded on exchanges such as MCX, rather than for equities.
Most investors end up holding some combination of all three, and they're usually linked to the same bank account for fund transfers, even though each account is opened, maintained, and regulated slightly differently depending on which exchange or depository it's tied to.
Do you need to close or replace an existing account?
No. Opening a demat account doesn't require closing or modifying any trading or commodity account you already hold, with Chola Securities or elsewhere. If your existing accounts are with a different broker, they remain fully independent of a new demat account opened with Chola Securities, and your existing holdings, funds, and positions stay exactly where they are.